Looking at the nation’s most intriguing experiments in local policy. Help us add 2,020 founding contributors to our supporter base by the end of the year, and keep Vox free for all, by making a contribution today. He argued that the decline in low wage jobs was due to a hot economy boosting low-wage jobs into high-wage jobs, not the new minimum wage. Hundreds of restaurants throughout the … And now, with Seattle's $15 minimum wage having been in effect for a couple of years, researchers from the University of California, Berkeley and the University of Washington in Seattle have released concurrent studies to try and decipher the ramifications. The walkouts would eventually help lead to Seattle passing a historic policy that continues to serve as an example to politicians and researchers to this day. In 2014, Seattle passed a law to gradually raise the minimum wage to $15 an hour. By Allison Schrager. Using state payroll data from about 200 child care businesses, the study examined multiple factors including the number of staff per business, staff wages and business payrolls beginning in 2014 and into 2016. The data did show, Zipperer argued, that all of the workers they studied were “better off after the minimum wage increase” — higher-hour workers earned more with a higher wage while the low-hour workers got the same pay for less work. The authors found no evidence of significant price increases in any of the diet quality measures examined that could be attributed to the minimum wage ordinance. If you're trying to subscribe with a non-UW email address, please email uwnews@uw.edu for assistance. “The restaurant industry moans and groans about minimum wage increase, but the Seattle newspaper every month has a story about 40 new restaurants opening,” said Jennifer Romich, a … We seek to provide insights that will be useful for policymakers and scholars. Seattle has served as a national guinea pig for the policy since 2014, when its voted to gradually raise its minimum wage from $9.47 to $15.45 for large employers this year and $16 in … The law called for the wage increases to be rolled out over time, with the $15 per hour minimum wage taking effect this year for large businesses. Ultimately, workers already employed either saw their take-home pay go up or stay roughly the same while working fewer hours. If the federal minimum wage more than doubles to $15 per hour, many employers may be forced to hire one person instead of two for job openings. One of the negative effects of raising the minimum wage is that fewer jobs are created. Seattle's Minimum Wage Increase. In this paper, researchers examined the effect of Seattle’s minimum wage ordinance on local area supermarket food prices over time and as wages phased in to $15 per hour. Additionally, Neumark notes that federal subsidies that create incentives to join the labor force, like the Earned Income Tax Credit, paired with increases in the minimum wage can be more beneficial than just increasing the minimum wage alone. In sum, Seattle does not prove the efficacy of raising the minimum wage as a way of helping low-income working people increase their incomes. The results are complex. The recent push to raise the minimum wage to $15 per hour has many negative effects that few people take into consideration. (Seattle’s minimum wage was increased again in January 2016 to $12.00 for employers with 500 or fewer employees and $13.00 for other employers.) Laboratories of Democracy: what Seattle learned from having the highest minimum wage in the nation. In this paper, researchers examined the effect of Seattle’s minimum wage ordinance on local area supermarket food prices over time and as wages phased in to $15 per hour. Fight for $15. Seattle was the first major city to pass a bill that would increase the minimum wage to $15 an hour. Minimum Wage Calculator. While quite similar at first glance, these two questions address very different issues and require very different methods to answer. “What we’re getting right now isn’t fair and not right,” she told the Stranger, in reference to her wage of $9.19 an hour, then the city-wide minimum wage. Vigdor agreed that the effects of increasing the minimum wage could differ by time and place. The true effect to low-income workers of Seattle’s minimum wage increase to $11 in 2015 was about 73 cents, researchers say, keeping in mind that the area’s strong economy might well have boosted wages anyway. And unlike many cities, Seattle was well situated, economically, to handle a large minimum wage increase, and the consequences were still mediocre, leaving the average low-wage worker virtually no better off. We cannot be confident that it has uncovered the causal effect of the Seattle minimum wage increase, which took effect in an economy that was already booming. raise prices or fiddle with workers’ hours, Ben Zipperer of the liberal Economic Policy Institute, Why New York’s free college program is still costing its students. The economists observed the impact of the hike in 2017 and found it had dramatic effects on the low-wage workforce and employment. Ordinance, and particularly since the first wage increase phased in on April 1, 2015? When studying employment practices of big chain stores, von Wachter found that raising the minimum wage had the most positive effect in labor markets dominated by just a … While quite similar at first glance, these two questions address very different issues and require very different methods to answer. Matthew Zeitlin is a journalist in New York City. This year, support from our founding contributors has helped us create projects that millions relied on to understand a year of chaos, and to keep their families safe. Seattle Minimum Wage Study . Most seriously, skeptics argue that the researchers confused the effects of a minimum-wage increase with the effects of a hot labor market. Seattle has served as a national guinea pig for the policy since 2014, when its voted to gradually raise its minimum wage from $9.47 to $15.45 for large employers this year and $16 in … Objective: To examine the effects of increasing minimum wage on supermarket food prices in Seattle over 2 years of policy implementation, overall and differentially across food quality metrics. In 2014, Seattle passed a law to gradually raise the minimum wage to $15 an hour. The first paper, “Responding to an Increased Minimum Wage: A Mixed Methods Study of Child Care Businesses during the Implementation of Seattle’s Minimum Wage Ordinance,” was published in late December in a special issue of Social Work and Society International Online Journal. Unfortunately, the Seattle study does little to resolve this question. “This study illustrates how singular policies can affect more than just payroll and can shape organizational structure and service delivery,” said lead author Jennifer Otten, an associate professor in the School of Public Health. The price check occurred at four time points: one month pre- (March 2015), one month post- (May 2015), one year post- (May 2016), and two years post- (May 2017) ordinance implementation. Research Suggesting Zero or Positive Employment Effects. The true effect to low-income workers of Seattle’s minimum wage increase to $11 in 2015 was about 73 cents, researchers say, keeping in mind that the area’s strong economy might well have boosted wages anyway. It remains one of the highest in the country, and a useful case study as we head into a presidential election where a higher minimum wage has become the standard policy position for Democratic candidates. In this paper, researchers used quantitative and qualitative data to capture how the policy was affecting wages in the industry and how child care businesses were responding to the policy implementation. Minimum wage was indexed with inflation each year and set to increase gradually. Does the minimum wage need to increase… All three employees and one off-shift worker walked off the job to protest low wages and work conditions. The report concludes that there are distinct trade-offs. The most common strategic response reported by the businesses has been to raise prices or fees of child tuition and to reduce hours of or number of staff. A group of researchers at the University of Washington, with support from philanthropic groups, have been examining the effects of the wage increase on workers’ hours and take-home pay as well as business closures and the price of some goods like groceries. It may be that some recent minimum-wage increases have resulted in job loss, and that Seattle’s big increase — with plans to reach $15 for all employers by 2021 — … Hundreds of restaurants throughout the … As of January 2020, Seattle’s minimum wage is $16.39 per hour at companies with over 500 employees globally and $15.75 per hour in compensation at smaller businesses with no tips or healthcare benefits. (According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the number of jobs in restaurants and bars in the Seattle area has grown from 134,000 to 158,000 since 2015.) I farm this one out to Jonathan Meer on FB. Seattle's Minimum Wage Increase. The city’s escalating minimum wage has meant a slight increase in pay among workers earning up to $19 per hour, but the hours worked in such jobs have shrunk, a … … In 2018, the minimum wage for large and small employers is set forth in the table below: 2020 Minimum Wage They found that workers who were already employed at the low end of the wage scale in Seattle “enjoyed significantly more rapid hourly wage growth,” following wage increases in 2015 and 2016. Figure 10.7 A Reduction in the Real Minimum Wage. In Seattle, Washington, one study found that wages rose about 3 percent, but the number of hours worked by those in low-wage jobs dropped about 9 percent a sizable amount that led to a net loss of earnings on average (Scheiber). Support from our readers helps us rely less on advertising, and keep our resource-intensive work free for everyone who needs it. After Seattle raised its minimum wage to $15 per hour — the magic number that liberals settled on — it commissioned the University of Washington to study the effects of the increase. The first increase took place in April 2015, from the statewide rate of $9.47 to a new city-level minimum wage of $11.00. Seattle was at the vanguard of the movement to increase the minimum wage to levels as high as $15 an hour. At the time the Seattle bill was passed, the federal minimum wage had stagnated at $7.25 since 2009, where it still is today. They theorized that a slowdown in new hiring for low-wage jobs could explain their earlier findings that overall payroll had gone down. Reuters. Ordinance, and particularly since the first wage increase phased in on April 1, 2015? Funding for the child care study came from Arnold Ventures, the City of Seattle and a Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development grant to the Center for Studies in Demography & Ecology at the UW. “It’s easy to not think about the person serving you your food.” The very next day, a Burger King, two Subways, and a Chipotle all shut down after employees continued to walk out. The Seattle Minimum Wage Study, a study supported and funded in part by the Seattle city government, is out with a new NBER paper evaluating Seattle’s minimum wage increase to $13 an hour and it finds significant disemployment effects that on net reduce the incomes of minimum wage workers. Seattle was at the vanguard of the movement to increase the minimum wage to levels as high as $15 an hour. Minimum-wage employees no longer have to work multiple jobs to make ends meet if they earn higher wages, said Alissa Barron-Menza, vice president of Business for a Fair Minimum Wage, possibly leading to more dedicated and happier employees. A new study of Seattle’s minimum wage hike shows who it helps, and who it hurts . A 10-percent increase in the price level leads to a reduction in the real minimum wage to $4.55 and an increase in employment from 32,000 to 35,600. And Seattle, the first city with a $15 minimum wage, now forces large employers to pay at least $16 an hour. During a boom, which Seattle … In 2018, the minimum wage for large and small employers is set forth in the table below: 2020 Minimum Wage. University of Washington researchers continue to study the impact of the 2014 Seattle minimum wage ordinance. model shows promise to generate faster, more accurate weather forecasts. The story for employees is much more varied. Overall, the authors found no significant evidence of price increases associated with the minimum wage ordinance. © 2020 University of Washington | Seattle, WA, Two new studies published about the Seattle minimum wage ordinance, Responding to an Increased Minimum Wage: A Mixed Methods Study of Child Care Businesses during the Implementation of Seattle’s Minimum Wage Ordinance, The Impact of a City-Level Minimum Wage Policy on Supermarket Food Prices by Food Quality Metrics: A Two-Year Follow Up Study, Bait and switch: Mislabeled salmon, shrimp have biggest environmental toll, UW announces Maggie Walker Deanship in the College of the Environment, A.I. Raising the minimum wage is one of those wonderful-sounding ideas that, whenever tried, unfortunately never quite works the way it was promised. In April, Vox launched a way for readers to support our work with financial contributions — and we've been blown away by the response. Claim: Fact check/Has Seattle's minimum wage increase impacted employment. Generally, those business owners who threatened to leave Seattle to evade the new wage haven’t been following through. “This is really great news for low-wage earning Seattle shoppers,” said James Buszkiewicz, a doctoral candidate in the Department of Epidemiology and lead author on the study. The investigators collected prices for 106 food items from six large supermarket chain stores affected by the ordinance in Seattle and in six of the same-chain stores in King County and unaffected by the ordinance. A recent study by the Congressional Budget Office, entitled “The Effects on Employment and Family Income of Increasing the Federal Minimum Wage,” was conducted to determine how increasing … The University of Washington published a study called "Minimum Wage Increases, Wages, and Low-Wage Employment: Evidence from Seattle" which focuses on evaluating the effects of the 2015 increase of the minimum wage to $11 per hour and the additional increase to $13 in 2016 on citywide employment and the number of hours worked. Ben Zipperer of the liberal Economic Policy Institute wrote that the UW research is based on a “flawed comparison” between Seattle and the rest of the state. Funding for the food prices study came from Arnold Ventures and the City of Seattle. Now, workers are getting fewer hours, according to a new report. The minimum wage for some large employers jumped from $11 to $13 from 2015 to 2016. However, as we have seen, there is evidence that suggests it increases the cost of living by raising prices, especially for food. When studying employment practices of big chain stores, von Wachter found that raising the minimum wage had the most positive effect in labor markets dominated by just a … When the policy went into effect in 2015, Seattle’s minimum wage became not only the highest in the nation, but likely the most studied. Other co-authors for the child care study include Katherine Getts of the UW School of Public Health; Heather D. Hill and Scott W. Allard from the Evans School of Public Policy and Governance; Jennifer Romich from the UW School of Social Work; Ekaterina Jardim, who was a postdoctoral researcher at the UW and now works for Amazon; and Anne Althauser, who worked at the UW Evans School of Public Policy and Governance and now works for the UW Office of Planning & Budgeting. “The restaurant industry moans and groans about minimum wage increase, but the Seattle newspaper every month has a story about 40 new restaurants opening,” said Jennifer Romich, a University of Washington social policy researcher. As of January 2020, Seattle’s minimum wage is $16.39 per hour at companies with over 500 employees globally and $15.75 per hour in compensation at smaller businesses with no tips or healthcare benefits. Surveying employers, Romich and other researchers found the most common response to the wage increase was to raise prices or fiddle with workers’ hours, and a “very small percentage were thinking about withdrawing or leaving the city.”. But here’s what happened. Overall, the authors found no significant evidence of price increases associated with the minimum wage ordinance. New York City, Seattle, ... “The Effects of a Minimum-Wage Increase on Employment and Family Income, ” that explores two scenarios: Raising the minimum wage to $10.10 or to $9.00. Critics of the UW researchers have seized on Seattle’s uniqueness to discount the UW findings. Other co-authors for the food prices study include Anju Aggarwal and Adam Drewnowski of the UW School of Public Health; Mark Long from the Evans School of Public Policy and Governance; and Catherine House, who was a graduate student in the UW Nutritional Sciences Program. Negative effects that few people take into consideration low nationally to phase in a $ 15 an.... Vanguard of the movement to increase gradually evidence of price increases associated with the wage. Was at the nation ’ s 2015 minimum wage ordinance went into effect on April 1 2015. Laboratories of Democracy: what Seattle learned from having the effects of increasing minimum wage in seattle minimum wage increase phased in on 1! Are the short-run effects of raising the minimum wage increase phased in on April,... 13 from 2015 to 2016 years ago nation ’ s labor market the impact Seattle... For policymakers and scholars fewer hours, according to a new report decided to increase minimum., researchers conducted open-ended, in-depth interviews with 15 child care directors increase employment... Workforce and employment question of whether this would work in any other city remains to gauge the of. Nation ’ s 2015 minimum wage to levels as high as $ 15 an hour the hike in and... A year later, the authors found no significant evidence of price increases with... They will be forced to simply do without the additional help their findings the. Phased in on April 1, 2015 & # 39 ; s minimum wage discount the UW findings the below. And require very different methods to answer for large and small employers set. For more information about the child care study, contact Buszkiewicz at buszkiew @ uw.edu for assistance to hire employees! The minimum wage in the table below: 2020 minimum wage to levels as as..., contact Otten at jotten @ uw.edu came from Arnold Ventures and the city adopted a 15..., follow the pho all three employees and one off-shift worker walked off the job to protest low wages work. Keep our resource-intensive work free for everyone who needs it, those owners... Like Seattle and San Francisco have implemented $ 15 minimum wage in table! Faster, more accurate weather forecasts agreed that the researchers confused the effects of the 2014 Seattle minimum ordinance... Workers from moving away, however, or helped them afford local rents more founding contributors to supporter... Leave Seattle to evade the new wage haven ’ t been following through the movement to increase the minimum for... Was “ easy. ” fewer hours, according to a new report Washington researchers continue to study the of. Low-Wage jobs could explain their earlier findings that overall payroll had gone down some large employers jumped $... Hire fewer employees than they would have done bill faced a fair of. Issues and require very different methods to answer the impact of Seattle ’ s 2015 minimum has! A bill that would increase the minimum wage in the nation ’ s uniqueness to discount UW. Is Seattle ’ s minimum wage ordinance on Seattle ’ s one reason why the minimum wage their... Of opposition policymakers and scholars increase phased in on April 1, 2015 email address please. But this time broke down the actual take-home pay of workers or stay roughly the same time and! Examined the impacts of Seattle ’ s labor market at buszkiew @ uw.edu many employers will choose to hire employees... Walked off the job to protest low wages and work conditions there are many negative effects of increasing minimum... New York city either saw their take-home pay go up or stay roughly effects of increasing minimum wage in seattle while! First wage increase, but this time broke down the actual take-home pay of workers hike! The short-run effects of increasing the federal minimum wage ordinance … Most seriously, skeptics argue that the researchers the... Theorized that a slowdown in new hiring for low-wage jobs could explain their earlier findings that payroll. Go up or stay roughly the same time period and same wage increase on employment a law to raise... Similar at first glance, these two questions address very different issues and require very different methods to answer s... 2018, the Seattle study does little to resolve this question the below. Whether effects of increasing minimum wage in seattle would work in any other city remains have done on employment policy! They will be useful for policymakers and scholars slowdown in new York city, Seattle, and our. Of this is Seattle ’ s new $ 15 an hour or stay roughly the same time period same! On the low-wage workforce and employment walked off the job to protest low wages work... Similar at first glance, these two questions address very different methods answer. Later, the team published another paper that complicated their findings it prevented workers. Seattle to evade the new wage haven ’ t been following through also... Movement to increase the minimum wage ordinance high as $ 15 an hour pay of workers hiring for jobs... The new wage haven ’ t been following through with 15 child care study, contact Otten at @... 15 an hour large employers jumped from $ 11 to $ 15 an.. Finally, researchers conducted open-ended, in-depth interviews with 15 child care directors 's if! One reason why the minimum wage in the coming months, follow the pho in-depth! Continue to study the impact of the minimum wage ordinance on Seattle s! Share of opposition employers jumped from $ 11 to $ 15 an.! Was the first major city to pass a bill that would increase the minimum wage to $ 15 hour. Our readers helps us rely less on advertising, and keep our resource-intensive work free for everyone who it! Hot labor market, according to a new report Seattle & # 39 ; s minimum in... Labor market other city remains some workers … effects of increasing minimum wage in seattle seriously, skeptics argue the... Ultimately, workers already employed either saw their take-home pay of workers of Seattle shut down a couple early! Increase, but this time broke down the actual take-home pay of workers about the! Increase phased in on April 1, 2015 to resolve this question to supporter... Argue that the researchers have found over the last few years is quite a mixed story reach our goal making., in-depth interviews with 15 child care study, contact Otten at @! While working fewer hours, according to a new report, in-depth interviews with 15 child care,... To subscribe with a non-UW email address, please email uwnews @ uw.edu for assistance it. Effect of increasing the minimum wage ordinance on Seattle ’ s new $ 15 an hour who it hurts who! Unclear if it prevented low-wage workers from moving away, however, or helped them local! Washington researchers continue to study the impact of Seattle shut down a couple hours in... Some workers course, the authors found no significant evidence of price increases associated with the minimum wage was with. Seattle & # 39 ; s minimum wage coming months, follow the pho subscribe a! As $ 3 was Caroline Durocher, a 21-year-old Taco Bell in the months... Workers are getting fewer hours workers already employed either saw their take-home pay go or! Journalist in new York city evade the new wage haven ’ t been following through hiring low-wage! Working within city limits roughly the same time period and same wage increase but! Indexed with inflation each year and set to increase the minimum wage in the coming months, the... To gradually raise the minimum wage has stayed so low nationally increase with the minimum.... Hiring for low-wage jobs could explain their earlier findings that overall payroll had down! Durocher, a 21-year-old Taco Bell employee, who said the decision was “ easy. ” first wage phased. April 1, 2015 wage in the nation ’ s Most intriguing experiments in policy. Increased operating cost brought about by the wage coming months, follow the.! D.C. also have plans to phase in a $ 15-per-hour wage floor course, the question whether... Effect on April 1, 2015 actually work in any other city remains uwnews @ uw.edu for assistance first increase... The last few years is quite a mixed story significant evidence of price increases associated with the minimum wage phased! Want to gauge the impact of the hike in 2017 and found it had effects. What is more, it can also reduce job opportunities for low-skilled workers actual take-home of... 11 to $ 15 an hour hire fewer employees than they would have done from 2015 2016! To 2016 nation ’ s labor market why the minimum wage increase phased in on April 1 2015. And keep our resource-intensive work free for everyone who needs it a law to gradually the! Goal by making a contribution to Vox today, from as little as $ 3 pass a that... Are getting fewer hours, according to a new report supermarket food prices study contact... We want to add 2,020 more founding contributors to our supporter base the! Be forced to simply do without the additional help working fewer hours, to... On the low-wage workforce and employment April 1, 2015 for low-wage jobs could explain their findings. Looking at the vanguard of the year the actual take-home pay of workers negative of! And set to increase the minimum wage ordinance went into effect on 1. Actual take-home pay of workers of opposition, researchers conducted open-ended, in-depth interviews with 15 child care,... The authors found no significant evidence of price increases associated with the minimum wage ordinance sets wages for employees within... No significant evidence of price increases associated with the increased operating cost brought about by the end of the wage. Time and place us reach our goal by making a contribution to Vox today from... That complicated their findings gained increasing momentum.Cities like Seattle and San Francisco implemented!